Well I took the 6 hour express way to the download of the KDE desktop environment for Ubuntu Jaunty Jackalope x64. Downloading from the repositories took almost 6.5 hours at 5-10kb/s. While waiting I did a little research and found that it would probably be pretty neat for my liking.
Well the install went flawlessly. It took a while and my terminal was pretty tired of outputing the information. I setup gnome as my default DE for now. I made a new account just for the use of KDE.
So far, my findings. I’ll list what I’ve found impressive, then the bad news on the backend.
Plasma… There’s just no explaining this. The desktop is absolutely unreal. Widget based, small windows with almost a limitless supply of information.. RSS feeds, Clocks, system monitors, and more! Pretty easy to use, and best of all you can lock them down.
However, using plasma, there’s a bit of a difference between the normal desktop environment like GDM(Gnome) or WDM(Windows Vista). There is no desktop folder that shows the icons directly to the “desktop” persay off the bat. It is changable though, either way by default there is a widget that allows you to browse the entire file system from a window! Pretty good idea if you like a clean shop as I do. I feel unclean with more than 3 icons on my desktop, so this is a good thing for me.
Control.. Absolutely beautiful set of controls. This is a BIG thing for KDE. The ability to control the environment and the “special” effects is unmatched in KDE. It’s an easy world there!
Ease… Oh how easy it is. The menu at first is confusing going from Gnome to KDE in a whole. The desktop is changed and the menu is streamlined for finishing touches for someone who has a LOT of menu options. I’ll stick to the simplistic gnome menu, but KDE would be much more user friendly in the long run I believe. Specially with the search bar added into the menu for direct searching for applications.
Now, there’s the good side. An absolutely eye tingling experience awaits the Kubuntu user with the KDE environment. However, there’s still downsides with KDE.
Stability.. On my first boot of KDE, “krunner” crashed with a fatal error. It quickly recovered and I was set. If you work to fast for it, like double clicking icons that a single click will open, it’ll crash. It recovers fine with no side effects, yet having to look at the red X of doom and a “Fatal Error” message every time you want to quick click. I’m a power user and my mouse is like lightning, so this is bad for me. However, slowing myself down and stopping the speed of my mousing has kept it from crashing at all.
Plasma can be irritating if you aren’t completely literate with a computer. Locking the widgets down isn’t the hardest thing to do, but it even took me a few minutes to figure out. Customization on the widgets isn’t as good as I’d like, but they work well.
The worst problem I see with a Gnome user switching to KDE is the panels. Gnome panels are awesome for the fact that they can be mutated to almost anything you want to use them for. KDE’s panels lack customization ability if you ask me. And the process is much more painful to mutate them and even to move them around! The effects are nice, but if I can’t manage them the way I want, what’s the point in having more then one? I don’t want one on top and it takes me more than 50 mouse clicks to move it? That’s a definite downside to me.
The final verdict?
KDE is more advanced in MANY ways compared to Gnome. It’s more visually perfect and looks great. Stability is questionable however, especially with krunner failures. There may be an easy fix, but compared to two years ago, it’s still not stable enough for what I’d call daily use.
KDE definitely has an advantage, but an extra 100mb or so of ram overhead. Plus it uses a bit more on the processor to run at an “idle”. However, with the visuals and more “windows like” appearance, KDE could definitely be the choice of many in the future. For now, I’ll stick to Gnome as my default desktop environment as its purpose is well fit into my daily Ubuntu and I don’t think I’d change that for anything. KDE will from now on remain installed in my desktop distro’s for “play time” though. It’s definitely showing of a better feel and better environment, it just needs to be stable like Gnome before it will take a home as my “everyday” environment.